COPE Psychological Center
cognitive processing therapy

6 Benefits of Prolonged Exposure and Cognitive Processing Therapy over EMDR

When it comes to trauma-focused treatments, there are various therapeutic options to explore. Prolonged Exposure (PE) and Cognitive Processing Therapy (CPT) are two widely used and well-researched approaches that focus on helping individuals process and heal from trauma, particularly post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). While Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) is also a popular trauma treatment, many clients and therapists find that PE and CPT offer distinct advantages. This blog explores the unique benefits of these two therapies and how they compare to EMDR.

What is Cognitive Processing Therapy?

Cognitive Processing Therapy (CPT) is a trauma-focused therapy designed to help individuals reframe unhelpful thought patterns caused by traumatic experiences. By targeting negative beliefs related to trauma, CPT encourages clients to challenge their perceptions and develop healthier, more balanced ways of thinking. CPT is particularly effective for individuals suffering from PTSD, as it addresses the cognitive distortions that keep trauma survivors stuck in their distress.

What is Prolonged Exposure Therapy?

Prolonged Exposure (PE) therapy is another well-established, evidence-based treatment for trauma. The primary goal of PE is to help individuals confront and process traumatic memories gradually, reducing the avoidance behaviors that often accompany PTSD. By repeatedly confronting the trauma in a safe and controlled environment, clients can desensitize themselves to the emotional and physiological responses associated with the memory, leading to reduced symptoms of PTSD.

6 Benefits of Prolonged Exposure and Cognitive Processing Therapy

1. Structured and Gradual Exposure in Prolonged Exposure

One of the major benefits of Prolonged Exposure (PE) therapy is its structured and gradual approach to confronting trauma. Unlike EMDR, which uses rapid techniques involving eye movements, PE allows clients to process traumatic memories at their own pace, with clear guidance from the therapist. This structured approach helps reduce avoidance behaviors that many trauma survivors develop.

PE begins with psychoeducation, where clients learn about the symptoms of trauma and how avoidance plays a role in maintaining distress. Clients then create a list of feared situations related to their trauma, starting with less anxiety-provoking scenarios and gradually moving toward more difficult ones. This incremental exposure helps clients build resilience and confront memories without becoming overwhelmed, making it a safe and empowering process.

2. Cognitive Restructuring in Cognitive Processing Therapy

Cognitive Processing Therapy (CPT) focuses on cognitive restructuring, which is one of the key advantages of this approach over EMDR. CPT helps individuals identify and challenge distorted beliefs resulting from trauma, such as feelings of guilt, shame, or helplessness. These unhelpful beliefs often prevent trauma survivors from moving forward and processing their emotions in a healthy way.

Through CPT, clients learn how to reframe these beliefs by asking themselves whether they are based on facts or assumptions. For example, a survivor of a car accident may feel that they are “weak” for not being able to prevent the crash, even though the event was outside of their control. By challenging these negative thoughts and replacing them with more realistic and compassionate perspectives, CPT helps clients develop healthier thought patterns and greater emotional resilience.

3. Adaptability for Complex Trauma

Both Prolonged Exposure and Cognitive Processing Therapy are highly adaptable for individuals with complex trauma histories, making them an excellent option for those who have experienced layered or chronic trauma. While EMDR is effective for many clients, it may not always address the range of issues that individuals with complex trauma face.

PE and CPT can be modified to address trauma that is chronic or repetitive, such as childhood abuse or ongoing exposure to violence. Therapists using these approaches can tailor the treatment to suit the unique needs of each client, ensuring that they are receiving personalized care. This adaptability allows clients to work through a variety of trauma-related issues, giving them the tools to heal in a way that is individualized and comprehensive.

4. Empirical Support for Prolonged Exposure and Cognitive Processing Therapy

One of the most significant benefits of PE and CPT over EMDR is the robust empirical support backing their effectiveness. Both therapies are backed by decades of research and have been shown to produce significant improvements for individuals with PTSD and other trauma-related disorders.

Numerous studies have demonstrated the effectiveness of PE and CPT in treating trauma-related symptoms, making them reliable choices for evidence-based treatment. 

Prolonged Exposure (PE) is one of the most extensively researched treatments for PTSD, having been examined in 65 randomized clinical trials (RCTs), with more studies underway. Meta-analyses (e.g., 4-10) indicate that PE is highly effective in reducing PTSD symptoms and in achieving remission from the disorder (e.g., 7).

The first RCT on PE, conducted by Foa and colleagues (1991), compared its effectiveness with Stress Inoculation Training (SIT), supportive counseling (SC), and a waitlist control (WL) among female survivors of sexual assault. While PTSD symptoms decreased across all groups post-treatment, the PE group showed the greatest reduction at the 3-month follow-up. Later studies by Resick and colleagues (2002) and Rothbaum, Astin, & Marsteller (2005) further supported PE’s superiority over waitlist groups and demonstrated its effectiveness on par with other trauma-focused treatments for female sexual assault survivors.

On average, 53% of individuals who start PE no longer meet the criteria for PTSD, with the success rate increasing to 68% among those who complete treatment. Long-term follow-up data reveals that 83% of patients who underwent PE no longer met the diagnostic criteria for PTSD six years after the initial treatment.

A review conducted by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (16), which used rigorous criteria to assess study quality, included 19 RCTs of PE. The review concluded that there is strong evidence supporting the effectiveness of exposure therapies like PE in reducing PTSD and depression symptoms, achieving remission from PTSD, and highlighting trauma-focused therapies like PE as the most effective treatment for PTSD.

Similarly, CPT has been found to significantly reduce PTSD symptoms by addressing the negative thought patterns and beliefs that stem from trauma.

EMDR has also been researched extensively and is found to be effective for many clients; however, PE and CPT are often considered more structured, providing clients with clear tools and frameworks to manage their symptoms and track progress.

5. Client Empowerment through Coping Skills

A key aspect of both Prolonged Exposure and Cognitive Processing Therapy is the empowerment of clients by providing them with effective coping skills. These therapies give clients the tools they need to manage trauma-related symptoms long after therapy ends, fostering long-term resilience.

In PE, clients are taught to use exposure techniques and relaxation strategies to handle anxiety-provoking memories and situations. By practicing these techniques regularly, individuals can feel more confident in their ability to cope with stress in the future. Similarly, CPT equips clients with cognitive skills to challenge irrational thoughts and beliefs, promoting healthier thinking patterns and emotional regulation.

While EMDR can be a helpful tool for trauma recovery, it is often less focused on empowering clients with practical skills to apply in their daily lives. The structured, skill-building nature of PE and CPT can give clients a sense of control and independence that enhances their healing journey.

6. Long-Term Benefits and Maintenance

The skills learned in Prolonged Exposure and Cognitive Processing Therapy can have long-lasting effects, contributing to better mental health and stability long after treatment concludes. Clients who complete these therapies often report a sustained improvement in PTSD symptoms and overall emotional well-being.

While EMDR can also lead to positive outcomes, PE and CPT tend to provide more lasting tools for managing trauma-related symptoms. The coping strategies learned through these therapies can be utilized as needed, giving clients ongoing support in navigating future challenges.

PE and CPT as Powerful Trauma Treatments

While EMDR is an effective treatment for many clients, Prolonged Exposure and Cognitive Processing Therapy offer unique benefits, particularly for those seeking structured, evidence-based interventions for trauma recovery. The gradual exposure in PE, combined with cognitive restructuring in CPT, allows clients to address both the emotional and cognitive aspects of trauma. Additionally, the adaptability, empirical support, and long-term empowerment offered by these therapies make them valuable tools for individuals with complex trauma histories.

Ready to Begin Your Healing Journey?

If you or a loved one is struggling with trauma-related symptoms, Prolonged Exposure and Cognitive Processing Therapy may be the solution you’ve been searching for. At COPE Psychological Center, our team of skilled therapists is dedicated to helping you overcome trauma and reclaim your life. Reach out today to schedule an appointment and start your journey toward healing with therapies designed to empower you for long-term success.

Take the First Step Toward Healing at COPE Psychological Center

Don’t wait another day to take control of your mental health. Our compassionate and experienced therapists are ready to help you navigate your trauma and move toward a brighter, more fulfilling future. Contact us today to schedule your consultation!



Let’s Talk

I Need Help